Redbook
July 1995
Winning on Appeal
The Hot New Female Lawyers
by Lois Romano
Marcia Clark isn't the only lawyer out there who's smart, strong, and female.
These legal eagles aren't afraid to use what comes naturally to a woman ... and
it's working.
A
few months ago you probably saw 0.J. Simpson prosecutor Marcia Clark grill Brian
"Kato" Kaelin into a sweat and reduce defense attorney F. Lee Bailey to a
trembling fury. You re probably also familiar with lawyer Leslie Abramson, whose
defense of Erik Menendez, who confessed with his brother to the murder of their
parents, was so compelling that the trial ended in a hung jury.
When Abramson defended Menendez two years ago, she was one of few women to
have achieved stardom in criminal law. But today some of the biggest names in
criminal law—and civil litigation—belong to women. Although talented, ambitious
women in other professions have had a tough time rising to the top, female
lawyers have been landing more and more of the hot cases.
Their arrival in the forefront of the legal world is partly a result of
numbers, Twenty-five percent of lawyers and 115 percent of law school students
are women.
But unlike their counterparts of 20 years ago, many of today's experienced
female lawyers are trusting what s often referred to as their female traits
instead of copying those of male lawyers A number of these legal eagles believe
that being a woman makes them particularly suited to practicing criminal and
civil law, "Everything I am as a woman can work for me in the courtroom," says
Suzelle Smith, a prominent Los Angeles litigator. "I have the advantage of
having been better trained than my male colleagues in relating to people. It s
easier for me to question a witness without being condescending, Juries pick tip
on the tone of your voice and your body language. The model of a shoot-‘em-up
aggressive courtroom style as a surefire way to win is a myth. I make just as
much headway being firm without being threatening."
Many female lawyers say they have also benefitted from what could be called
an outsiders mentality, which has kept them focused on their clients best
interests and riot on what their male colleagues think of them, Victoria
Toensing. the Washington. D.C.. lawyer who recently negotiated a landmark
discrimination case for a female client against the CIA. claims that male
lawyers are too caught up in being one of the guys,"Women do not have a stake in
perpetuating the old-boy network," she says, "because the old boys are never
going to help them. This empowers women to go for the jugular. All men do is pat
each other on the rear end --and this does nothing for the client."
If the old boys tend to look out for one another, some also like to play out
their egos in the courtroom. When this happens, according to University of
Pennsylvania law professor Loni Guinier, it can distract from the issues of a
case, "F. Lee Bailey is the classic male lawyer who, with enormous bravado,
keeps the attention on him self," she says. "Some cases cannot be won if the
jury is diverted from the evidence by lawyer theatrics."
Guinier, who recently cowrote a study that examined the effect of her law
schools teaching methods on female students, believes some women have a distinct
advantage in the practice of courtroom law. "Many have been socialized to do
well as listeners, to establish rapport, and to be caring interviewers," she
says, "Since all lawyers are trained to be performers and aggressors, empathetic
women can have an advantage over those who have learned how to talk, but not how
to listen"
And when it comes to dress, today s high-powered female lawyers have to some
extent rewritten the code. Gone are the mannish pinstripes and bow ties. Now
they wear bright, stylish suits and dresses that they believe send a positive
message to the judge and jury. Nancy Hollander, a criminal defense attorney in
Albuquerque, New Mexico, says that when she faces off against
male lawyers in blue suits, her feminine dresses "perk up jurors, and they pay
more attention to what I have to say." Rikki Klieman. a Court TV anchor and
longtime litigator, always wears white for her opening and closing statements,
"It subliminally signals to the jury a certain purity, an innocence."
As women lawyers bring their own sensibilities to the profession. are the old
boys running scared? Not exactly, but they are looking over their shoulders. As
they should be. Because six women we talked to (and a good many others) are
giving them a real run for their money in the courtroom.
The Right Touch
Suzelle Smith, half of the Los Angeles firm of Howarth & Smith. wins
multi-million-dollar settlements for her clients by unabashedly playing the
gender card. In a successful 1988 damage suit brought against a shopping mall
from which a 26-year-old woman was abducted, raped, and later murdered, the
civil litigator bet on a strategy that would make the jury identify her with the
slain woman. A key move was to seat herself alone at the attorney's table and
place her clients—the victim s parents and husband—behind her in the public
seats.
When she recently represented workers at a nuclear plant who claimed to be
contaminated by radiation, she relied on her experience as a mother.
"In legal circles, it s said that a lawyer should talk to a jury as if it
were a class of sixth graders," she says. "That s not meant as an insult. The
fact is juries have to deal with issues and technicalities of which they have
little or no knowledge. Complex cases have to be broken down into their
components—even for judges. As a woman and the mother of a 5- and 8-year-old, I
am used to teaching and explaining."
Smith has also found touching to be an effective tactic. "I will walk around
an opposing lawyer and put my hands on his shoulder." explains the 41-year-old
Birmingham, Alabama, native. "I am
signaling the jury that I am in control of this situation, it works for me, but
could backfire for a male lawyer because men are seen as predators. His touching
me is viewed as a violation
of my space."
|